16 REVIEWS

Vinyl Reviews

Musical analysis, pressing history and buying guide. Every record reviewed as it deserves.

Karen Dalton — In My Own Time
9.6
FOLK
Karen Dalton
In My Own Time
1971 · Just Sunshine Records

A voice that wasn't seeking recognition — which is probably why no one who heard it ever forgot it.

Scott Walker — Scott 4
9.4
ART POP
Scott Walker
Scott 4
1969 · Philips Records

The moment a pop idol chose Bergman over the charts and never looked back.

Shuggie Otis — Inspiration Information
9.5
SOUL
Shuggie Otis
Inspiration Information
1974 · Epic Records

A twenty-year-old, a studio, every instrument. The future of soul recorded in the silence of Los Angeles.

Curtis Mayfield — Superfly
9.1
SOUL
Curtis Mayfield
Superfly
1972 · Curtom Records

Mayfield wrote against his own film — and the tension between the music and the image is where the masterpiece lives.

Sly & The Family Stone — There's a Riot Goin' On
9.4
FUNK
Sly & The Family Stone
There's a Riot Goin' On
1971 · Epic Records

The record where Sly Stone dismantled everything he'd built — and the wreckage turned out to be art.

Love — Forever Changes
9.8
PSYCH
Love
Forever Changes
1967 · Elektra Records

This is not a psychedelic record. Not folk-rock. Not even a work of art in the conventional sense. Forever Changes is something rarer: a prophecy pressed into vinyl by a man who believed he was about to die.

Led Zeppelin — Physical Graffiti
9.7
ROCK
Led Zeppelin
Physical Graffiti
1975 · Swan Song Records

When a band stops making records and starts building cathedrals. Seventy-six minutes in which Led Zeppelin set themselves no limits whatsoever — and it shows.

Miles Davis — Kind of Blue
10
JAZZ
Miles Davis
Kind of Blue
1959 · Columbia Records

When the silence between notes begins to weigh as much as the notes themselves.

The Smiths — The Queen Is Dead
9.8
INDIE ROCK
The Smiths
The Queen Is Dead
1986 · Rough Trade Records

Thirty-six minutes to redefine what a pop song can be. Then the break-up. Then silence.

Fleetwood Mac — Rumours
9.5
ROCK
Fleetwood Mac
Rumours
1977 · Warner Bros. Records

Five people doing harm to each other — and making the most beautiful thing of their lives.

Joni Mitchell — Blue
9.8
FOLK
Joni Mitchell
Blue
1971 · Reprise Records

A record that never learned to lie — and has never stopped hurting.

Ferris Wheel — Supernatural Girl
8.5
PSYCH FOLK
Ferris Wheel
Supernatural Girl
1974 · Nicro

A record cut in someone's living room in 1974. Nobody knew. Very few still do.

Dire Straits — Dire Straits
9
ROCK
Dire Straits
Dire Straits
1978 · Vertigo

February 1978, Basing Street Studios, London. Four musicians who didn't shout in an era that was all about shouting.

Lonnie Liston Smith — Astral Traveling
8.5
JAZZ
Lonnie Liston Smith
Astral Traveling
1973 · Flying Dutchman Records

Jazz that sounds like prayer — or like the moment just before you fall asleep among the stars.

Brian Eno — Ambient 1: Music for Airports
9.6
AMBIENT
Brian Eno
Ambient 1: Music for Airports
1978 · Polydor

The record that taught silence to become music.

Television — Marquee Moon
9.5
ROCK
Television
Marquee Moon
1977 · Elektra Records

Two guitars that don't play together — they play around each other, like snakes that never quite touch.